Why Do Canada and the United States Celebrate Thanksgiving on Different Days?

Two calendars with leaves and pumpkin in front showing October and November text When's Thanksgiving Canada & the U.S.

 

“The year that is drawing towards its close, has been filled with the blessings of fruitful fields and healthful skies.”

— Abraham Lincoln, Thanksgiving Proclamation, October 3, 1863.

Every autumn, families across Canada and the United States gather around tables filled with turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie. The celebrations are pretty much the same, but by the time Americans sit down for their Thanksgiving dinners, Canadians have already packed away the leftovers more than a month earlier.

Picking the current dates for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving has moved around the calendar in both countries, sometimes even sharing a date with other holidays and occasionally causing considerable controversy. At one point, Canadians celebrated Thanksgiving alongside with Remembrance Day, and Americans couldn't even agree on which Thursday should be Thanksgiving!

The tradition of gathering to celebrate a successful harvest is much older than either Canada or the United States. For centuries, communities across Europe marked the end of the growing season with feasts, music and celebrations and those were brought with them as people settled into their new countries in North America. For centuries celebrations like Michaelmas or Harvest Home were associated with the autumn harvest, when families might gather for a meal of roasted goose or a roast along with other seasonal foods.

Of course, Indigenous peoples across North America also had longstanding traditions of celebrating harvests and expressing gratitude for the land and its resources. These observances existed long before European settlers arrived and varied among communities.

Over time, all of these different celebrations developed into the Thanksgiving holidays we know today. But it turns out deciding exactly when everyone should celebrate proved surprisingly difficult.

Canada's Thanksgiving Dates

Canada's Thanksgiving celebrations once took place in November, much closer to the American holiday. In 1879, the government declared November 6 a national day of Thanksgiving, although the date continued to change in subsequent years. Following the First World War, they made an unusual decision. In 1921, Thanksgiving and Armistice Day were combined into a single holiday, observed on the Monday of the week containing November 11. 

It's hard to picture but imagine attending a solemn ceremony to remember soldiers who had died in the war in the morning, then spending the afternoon enjoying a Thanksgiving feast or watching a sporting event. For many Canadians, the combination simply didn't feel appropriate. Veterans and their supporters argued that November 11 deserved its own day of remembrance, separate from the festivities of Thanksgiving. Some communities continued to hold remembrance ceremonies on November 11, regardless of the official holiday date.

Eventually, the government agreed that these needed to be celebrated on their own dates. In 1931, November 11 became Remembrance Day, and Thanksgiving returned to the month of October. Yet even then, the holiday hadn't found its permanent place on the calendar. In fact, it wasn't until 1957 that Canada officially settled on the second Monday in October, a date that also suited the earlier autumn harvest in much of the country. 

Thanksgiving Picture Books We Love

American's Thanksgiving Dates

Meanwhile, next door the United States had its own problems deciding when Thanksgiving should take place.  In 1789, President George Washington proclaimed November 26 a national day of thanksgiving. However, celebrations continued to vary until 1863, when Abraham Lincoln called for Thanksgiving to be observed annually on the last Thursday in November.

For decades, that tradition continued but then, in 1939, President Franklin D. Roosevelt decided to change it.

That year, the last Thursday of November fell on November 30, leaving fewer shopping days before Christmas. With the country still recovering from the Great Depression, retailers worried that a shorter Christmas shopping season would hurt business. President Roosevelt announced that Thanksgiving would be celebrated one week earlier, on November 23, hoping the extra shopping days would encourage spending.

Not everyone was pleased and while some states accepted the new date, others refused to abandon the traditional last Thursday of November. Families, schools and businesses suddenly faced the peculiar situation of having two different Thanksgiving holidays. 32 states followed Roosevelt's earlier date, while 16 states kept November 30. The disagreement continued the following year, creating confusion over holiday travel, school schedules and family gatherings.

This controversy even earned the earlier celebration Thursday the nickname Franksgiving, combining the president's first name with Thanksgiving. Finally, in 1941, Congress settled the matter by establishing the fourth Thursday in November as the federal Thanksgiving holiday.

Today's Thanksgiving Dates

Canadians continue to celebrate Thanksgiving on the second Monday in October, while Americans gather on the fourth Thursday in November. These dates might seem set in stone, one has to wonder based on the many changes in the not too distant past, these months and dates have moved around quite a bit and perhaps will do so again in the future.

Although the holidays developed through different historical events, they share familiar customs rooted in centuries of harvest celebrations and traditions of giving thanks. From Michaelmas feasts and autumn harvest gatherings to changing government proclamations and competing Thanksgiving Thursdays, the history of this holiday is a reminder that even our most familiar traditions have changed over time.

And whether the Thanksgiving table is set in October or November, the custom of gathering together to share food and gratitude continues all across Canada and the United States every fall.

A Note from Little Goodbyes Press

As we continue exploring the origins of familiar celebrations and customs through our Changing Traditions series, Thanksgiving is another tradition we're thinking that we'd like to explore in a future picture book. 

You can explore all of our current titles on our Books Page.

If you'd like to help share our works, visit our Libraries Page for circulation details and ISBNs.

Our books are available through major retailers including Chapters, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Bookshop, and Waterstones.

Want to check out our book trailers and other short videos? You can find them all on our YouTube Channel and on our TikTok account, where we've been experimenting with different illustrations, music, and ways to introduce our books to new audiences. 

Popular posts from this blog

Working with Scribus: A Free InDesign Alternative for Book Layouts

ISBNs in Canada (and Why I’m Using IngramSpark)

Weaning Picture Books that Toddlers Love